Guide · Packaging artwork

Packaging teams tell us the same thing: approvals move in “sequential bottlenecks”, and one file’s rework holds up every other SKU in the batch. Printers and customers wait in line too, and compliance sign-off ends up as an email nobody can find.

This guide shows how to give each file its own approval, who should review packaging artwork, and what to check before it goes to print.

No credit card needed. Reviewers are always free.

What is an artwork approval workflow?

An artwork approval workflow is the set route a packaging or label file takes from first proof to “approved for print”. It names who reviews each file (brand, regulatory, quality, the retailer, the printer), what each of them checks, and who gives the final sign-off.

A good one gives every file its own approval, so a fix on one SKU doesn’t hold up the others.

  • One file = one approval
  • Reviewers chosen by role, marked required or optional
  • A clear Approved or Changes requested from each reviewer

Why sequential approval stalls

In a sequential chain, a whole batch of artwork moves from one reviewer to the next. When one file needs changes, everything waits.

Sequential: the batch moves as one

Regulatory asks for a fix on SKU 3. All four SKUs go back, and quality, the retailer and the printer haven’t started.

Sequential approval chain A batch of four SKUs passes Brand, then stops at Regulatory because SKU 3 needs changes. Quality, Retailer and Printer are waiting. The batch goes back to the start. 1. BrandApproved 2. RegulatoryChanges 3. QualityWaiting 4. RetailerWaiting 5. PrinterWaiting back to start Batch of 4 SKUs SKU 1 · waits SKU 2 · waits SKU 3 · fix SKU 4 · waits 0 of 4 to print

Parallel: one file, one approval

Every reviewer gets every file at once. SKU 3 goes to version 2; SKUs 1, 2 and 4 go to the printer.

Parallel approval per file Four SKUs, each reviewed at the same time by Brand, Regulatory, Quality, Retailer and Printer. SKUs 1, 2 and 4 are approved. SKU 3 has changes requested by Regulatory and moves to version 2 on its own. BrandReg.QualityRetailPrinter SKU 1 Approved SKU 2 Approved SKU 3 ! Changes → v2 SKU 4 Approved 3 of 4 to print · only SKU 3 waits

Rework travels with the batch

In a chain, one change sends every file back through every reviewer. A simple fix on one SKU can add days to the others.

Late reviewers find issues late

The printer and the retailer often sit at the end. Their notes on bleed, barcodes or shelf rules arrive after everyone else has signed off.

Nobody can see where a file is

With the batch in one email thread, it’s hard to tell which file is waiting on whom, and which version each person approved.

How to set up parallel approval per file

You don’t need new software to start. You need four rules that everyone on the round follows.

  1. One file = one approval. Each SKU, flavour or pack size gets its own file and its own decision. Don’t approve a batch as a single item.
  2. Pick reviewers by role, not by habit. Name one person per role for each file (see the table). Fewer, clearer reviewers make faster rounds.
  3. Mark each reviewer required or optional. A file is approved when every required reviewer says Approved. Optional reviewers can comment, but they don’t hold the file.
  4. Send every file to every reviewer at once. Rework on one file starts a new version of that file only. The other SKUs keep moving.

Need a formal order, for example compliance signing off before the printer sees a file? Use stages per file: stage 1 runs in parallel, stage 2 opens once stage 1 is approved. The other files still move on their own.

RoleWhat they checkUsually
Brand / marketingDesign, brand name and logo use, claims wording, colour intentRequired
Regulatory / complianceMandatory text, allergens, net quantity, nutrition panel, claims substantiated, both languagesRequired
Quality / R&DIngredients and nutrition match the current formula and specRequired
The retailerRetailer-specific rules, shelf and barcode needs, private-label requirementsRequired for retailer packs; optional otherwise
The printerDieline, bleed, ink and colour callouts, file specsRequired before print
Agency / designerReads feedback and uploads the next versionOptional (they fix, not approve)
PRINTABLE CHECKLIST

Packaging artwork checklist

Run this on every file, every version, before you mark it approved. Adapt it to your market’s labelling rules.

  • Allergen statementMatches the current formula. Allergens shown the way your market requires, including any “may contain” line.
  • Net quantity in metric unitsCorrect figure and unit, in the required place and type size. Imperial too, if your market asks for it.
  • Bilingual text matchesBoth languages say the same thing: product name, ingredients, allergens, claims and directions.
  • Nutrition panelValues match the latest spec sheet. Format and serving size suit the target market.
  • Barcode / UPC placement and quiet zoneRight number for this SKU. Clear margin around the bars, not over a fold or seam, at a scannable size. Test it with a barcode verifier.
  • Colour calloutsPantone or CMYK callouts match the brand spec. Compare against the signed-off colour standard.
  • DielineArtwork sits on the current dieline version. Bleed, safe area, folds and glue areas are clear of text.
  • Claims substantiatedEvery claim on pack has evidence on file and a named approver.
  • Brand name spelled consistentlySame spelling, case and trademark symbols on every panel and in both languages.
  • Printer specsFile format, resolution, bleed, ink count and minimum line or text sizes match what the printer asked for.
  • Mandatory detailsCompany name and address, country of origin, storage and use directions, and space for the lot and date code.
  • Version and sign-offThe file being approved is the latest version. Each required reviewer has given a decision on it.

Why it matters: labelling errors caused 71.1% of major-allergen recalls with a known cause in FDA data for FY2013 to 2019 (Food Safety Magazine, Apr 2023). This checklist is a starting point, not legal advice.

VERSIONS

Versions and “what changed”

Most rework rounds go wrong in the same place: a reviewer approves version 4 without seeing what changed since version 3. A missing allergen line or a reworded claim slips through.

  • Name versions, not files. Keep one file per SKU and add versions to it. “Final_v3_REAL.pdf” is how the wrong file reaches the printer.
  • Reset approvals on a new version. An approval belongs to the version that was reviewed, not to the file.
  • Compare before you approve. Put the new version next to the last approved one and read what moved.
Available today

PDF side-by-side compare

In zipBoard, open two versions of a PDF side by side, each with its own comments. Changed text is highlighted, so copy edits are easy to spot. How it works

Coming soon

Image and overlay compare

Visual compare for images and layouts is on the way. Until then, check colour and layout changes by eye, side by side.

How to do this in zipBoard

Keep it simple. Most packaging rounds need three steps.

1. Upload the artworkOne file per SKU: a print PDF or image exported from Illustrator or InDesign. Add new versions to the same file.
2. Send one linkBrand, regulatory, quality, the retailer and the printer comment in the browser, with no account. Add a password or expiry if you need to.
3. Get a decisionEach reviewer marks Approved or Changes requested on each file. A new version resets that file’s approvals.

Need formal sign-off? Add stages

Set required reviewers per file, each giving Approved or Changes requested, with a due date. Add stages (one board per stage, e.g. Brand → Regulatory → Printer) on every plan. Required reviewers

See what’s waiting on whom

Set due dates so late reviews show up. My Work shows each reviewer what needs their review, new versions since they reviewed, and what’s due soon or overdue, across projects. How it works

Why teams pick zipBoard

  • Reviewers never need an account or training. Printers and retailers click a link and comment.
  • Find everything waiting on you. My Work lists what needs your review and what’s due soon or overdue, across projects. Global Asset View searches every file.
  • Nothing gets missed. Each comment can carry an owner and a status, so fixes get closed, not lost in threads.

Reviewers and collaborators are unlimited on every plan. Only the people who manage projects need a seat.

Printers and retailers join as guests on their own link. Keep internal discussion in your team’s review. Feedback stays as “what to fix” on the artwork. Share link options

Which tool fits your artwork approval?

Three common setups, described in general terms. The right one depends on how many SKUs you run and how much checking you want the software to do.

What you decide onA review & approval tool (like zipBoard)Spreadsheets and emailDedicated artwork management
Best forBrand and packaging teams that want a simple per-file approval with inside and outside reviewersA handful of SKUs a year and a small, fixed group of reviewersHigh SKU counts, regulated labels, and teams that want the software to run technical checks
Parallel approval per fileYes: each file has its own reviewers, decisions and versionsPossible, but tracked by hand in a tracker sheetUsually yes, often with serial and parallel routing
Printers and retailers as reviewersComment from a link, no account neededAttachments by email; feedback comes back in many formsUsually supported through supplier or external user access
Record of who approved whatDecision per reviewer per versionSpread across inboxesTypically a full audit trail; some offer e-signatures for regulated sign-off
Compare versionsPDF side by side with changed text highlighted; image compare coming soonBy eyeTypically visual compare, such as overlay, difference or pixel views
Colour and barcode checksNot included: check with your printer’s proof and a barcode verifierNot includedTypically built in (for example colour callout and barcode checks)
Regulatory content workflowsA person checks against your checklist; required reviewers per file, stages on every planA person checks against your checklistOften included: rule sets for label content and copy management
Other files the team reviewsAlso video, HTML5 banners, web pages and documentsAnything you can attachFocused on packaging and labels
Setup effortUpload a file and send a linkNone, until the tracker growsUsually an implementation project

Examples of dedicated artwork platforms, from their own sites, opened 16 Nov 2026: ManageArtworks lists workflows with “serial and parallel routing”, 1D and 2D barcode inspection, Spot, CMYK and Pantone colour analysis, pixel-by-pixel comparison and Part 11 / Annex 11 features. Artwork Flow lists three compare modes, barcode and QR code verification, Pantone and CMYK checks, multi-stage approvals and rulebooks for label compliance. Check each vendor for current plans.

When you need a dedicated artwork platform instead

A review and approval tool like zipBoard keeps the round simple. Choose a dedicated artwork management platform if:

  • You want the software to check barcodes, colours or separations. zipBoard doesn’t do that. Your printer’s proof and a barcode verifier still do.
  • You need visual overlay compare on every proof today. Our image compare is coming soon.
  • You label regulated products such as pharma, OTC or medical devices, and need 21 CFR Part 11 e-signatures. zipBoard isn’t built for that.
  • You manage label copy as structured content across hundreds of SKUs and markets, with rule sets for each.
  • A vendor SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate is a hard requirement. We don’t hold either; we complete security questionnaires on request. See Security at zipBoard.

Many teams start with simple per-file approval and add a dedicated platform only when SKU counts or regulation demand it.

Coming soon

Coming soon

Image and overlay compare

Compare two versions of artwork to spot visual changes, not just text.

Tell me when it’s ready →

Coming soon

InDesign plugin

Send labels and layouts for review and see feedback without leaving InDesign.

Tell me when it’s ready →

Coming soon

Monday.com integration

Connect artwork review and approval to the Monday.com boards where your packaging work already runs.

Tell me when it’s ready →

Artwork approval: common questions

What is an artwork approval workflow?

It’s the set route a packaging or label file takes from first proof to approved for print. It names who reviews each file, what they check and who gives final sign-off. A good one gives every file its own approval.

Should packaging artwork be approved in sequence or in parallel?

In parallel per file, for most teams. Sequential chains create “sequential bottlenecks”: one file’s rework sends the whole batch back. If compliance must sign off before the printer, use stages per file, so each file still moves on its own.

Who should review packaging artwork?

Usually brand or marketing, regulatory or compliance, quality or R&D, the retailer for retailer packs, and the printer. Name one person per role and mark each as required or optional.

How can printers and retailers review artwork without an account?

In zipBoard they open a share link and comment in the browser. You can add a password, require sign-in or set an expiry date. Reviewers are unlimited on every plan.

How do I see what changed between two artwork versions?

Put the new version next to the last approved one. In zipBoard, PDF versions open side by side with changed text highlighted. Image and overlay compare is coming soon.

Does zipBoard check barcodes or colours on packaging?

No. zipBoard handles review and approval: feedback on the artwork and a decision per reviewer. Use your printer’s proof and a barcode verifier for those checks, or a dedicated artwork platform if you want them built in.

Can we have a formal compliance step with a clear approval?

Yes. Make compliance a required reviewer on each file; the file isn’t approved until every required reviewer marks it Approved. To give compliance its own stage, add a stage for it.

Does zipBoard have SOC 2 or ISO 27001?

No, we don’t hold either at present. We complete security questionnaires on request, offer SSO on Enterprise and can run you on a private instance. See Security at zipBoard.

Try per-file approval on your next pack

Upload one SKU’s artwork, add who must sign off, and send the link to your team, the retailer and the printer.

No credit card needed. Reviewers are always free.

Related Post